Love Jihad or Predatory Dawah?

byMonicca Agarwaal,Monika Arora,Shruti Mishra,Sonali Chitalkar

Shocking Ground Stories of Conversion

Primary research into thirteen documented cases of interfaith coercion and conversion by a Delhi-based academic group, with legal analysis.

Buy on GarudaLife

Overview

On 27 October 2020, Nikita Tomar was shot dead in broad daylight outside her college in Ballabhgarh, Haryana, returning from her final year examination. The case drew noise, then silence. When the Group of Intellectuals and Academicians (GIA) — a Delhi-based research collective of teachers, lawyers, journalists, and entrepreneurs — visited her family and began documenting similar cases, what emerged was not a political controversy but a pattern: grooming, identity concealment, coercion, sexual predation, and conversion carried out under the cover of relationship.

This book presents primary research across thirteen documented cases — Nikita, Tara Shahdeo, Sruthi, Rajni, and others — alongside a review of the legal framework governing interfaith marriage in India. The GIA's investigators interviewed the women and their families directly, producing records that vested media coverage had either distorted or ignored. The questions at the heart of this research are legal, social, and theological: what Shariah law requires of interfaith couples, how religious motivation shapes the documented patterns of exploitation, and whether the existing legal system is equipped to address any of it.

For parents, advocates, and anyone trying to understand what lies beneath the political noise around this subject, the documented testimonies here are the primary source.

-:ABOUT THE BOOK:-

What are the real heartbreaking stories of Non-Muslim women (and men) in inter-faith relationships with Muslims? What are the basic legal and social implications of such alliances that both men and women entering them should know? Are such relationships based on a premise of religious superiority and hegemony of Islam? Is there either 'Love' or 'Jihad' imbibed in such relationships? Were inter-faith unions a mechanism for the spread of Islam? 

Can such liasions survive the pre-requisites of Shariah law? And is the overwhelming complexity and brutality of such relationships a manifestation of predatory Dawah? These fundamental questions are addressed in this book which is based on primary research by Group of Intellectuals and Academicians (GIA). 

Due to the rhetoric and aggressive discourse building on 'Love-Jihad' done by comprador media and embedded agencies of the international Left, genuine tragedy and loss faced by victims has been denied. 

This book lays bare the agony of victims and families who have been targeted by predatory Dawah-a larger and more fundamental push for conversion by many means. This includes targeted weaponisation of love, sexual predation, economic exploitation, compulsion to fight religious wars (Jihad), etc. 

Unless society and the law recognize the suffering of these victims, justice for these women is a far cry. This book is an important read for parents and youth as well as a call for recognition of the severe gender injustice committed against the documented individuals.

-:CONTENTS:-

1. Interfaith Marriages and Provisions of Law in India
2. Nikita Tomar:
A Case of Murder of a Hindu Woman for Refusal to Convert to Islam
3. Tara Shahdeo
A Tragic Tale of Falsification of Identity, Subsequent Marriage and Conversion to Islam
4. Lalita (Name Changed):
A Case of Weaponisation of Love
5. Meenu (Name Changed):
A Case of Religious Falsehood, Relentless Pursuit, Sexual Exploitation and Abandonment
6. Saumya:
A Case of Conversion and Weaponisation of Love
7. Neha (Name Changed):
A Case of Being Lured into a Relationship under False Pretenses, a Tale of Horror and Brutality
8. Aiswarya:
A Story of Sexual Exploitation, Gang Pursuit and Suicide
9. Kavita (Name Changed):
A Case of Identity Concealment and Exploitation
10. Priya Sharma (Name Changed)
Relentless Pursuit, Marriage and Rape in Faraway Lands: A Story of an Orphan and Her Ordeal
11. Christina Maria (Name Changed)
Relentless Pursuit, Rape and Exploitation of a Christian Girl
12. Sruthi
Story of Sruthi – Psychological Manipulation and Conversion to Islam
13. Rajni:
A Case of Concealed Identity, Forced Conversion to Islam and Betrayal of a Hindu Woman

-:PREFACE:-

On 27 October, 2020, Nikita Tomar, returning from her final year examination was brutally murdered in broad daylight at Ballabhgarh, Haryana. A bright star of her family, she faced no restrictions at home. Her family supported her every attempt to fly high. Yet her wings were clipped, and she was murdered.

A number of questions arose in our minds. The whys and whats were answered when the Group of Intellectuals and Academicians (GIA) made a fact-finding visit to the victim’s house. This fact finding also led to more such cases coming to our notice. The GIA met and spoke to many women who had stories of grooming, pursuit and conversion to tell. What we unearthed were sordid tales of physical and sexual exploitation in which religious motivation played a significant role. 

The Group of Intellectuals and Academicians (GIA) is a group of women dedicated to the pursuit of research-based evidence and intervention on key social and political issues. Based in New Delhi, the group comprises professionals from different disciplines—teachers, lawyers, media persons and entrepreneurs.

GIA undertook a project to meet, interview and document cases that fall within the spectrum of inter-religious relationships. This is a compilation of such cases.

Grooming, Love bombing and Love Jihad are issues that must concern all communities, and the Hindus-Sikhs-Muslims-Christians need to converge to agree that radical religious pursuit of any woman is not permissible when the facade of ‘love’ is used as a pretext for conversion. This is pure savagery against women.

During this journey, we realized that not only are the women victimised in inter-faith relationships, marginalized by law enforcement and society but their bodies are also political booty. Their own stories get lost in the political din raised around choice in relationships. Very often vested media has tried to falsify these experiences through deceit and subterfuge.

The research and data compiling for this project was undertaken by Monika Arora, Sonali Chitalkar, Monicca Agarwaal, Shruti Mishra, Vijeta Aggarwal and Ambika. We are thankful to Shresth Tiwari for his research inputs into this project. Akash Vajpayee has also contributed to the writing of this book. Special thanks to Dr. Pratibha Singh for her contribution towards this project.

 
 
 

Author

Monika Arora photo
Monika Arora

Monika Arora (born 28 August 1973) is an Indian advocate practising in the Supreme Court of India, the Delhi High Court and the District Courts. She has served as Standing Counsel for the Government of India in the Delhi High Court and is a co-author of the widely-discussed Garuda Prakashan title Delhi Riots 2020: The Untold Story . She is one of the founders of the Group of Intellectuals and Academicians (GIA), a public-interest forum which has produced fact-finding reports and policy commentary on contentious questions of Indian public life - most prominently a citizen fact-finding report on the February 2020 Delhi riots that fed directly into the book. Read the full biography Delhi Riots 2020: The Untold Story , co-authored with Sonali Chitalkar and Prerna Malhotra, is an investigation into the February 2020 communal violence in north-east Delhi. The book attracted international attention after its original publisher withdrew it ahead of release; Garuda Prakashan picked it up and brought it out in 2020, where it became one of the year's most-read non-fiction releases in Indian publishing. Arora's legal practice spans constitutional law, public-interest litigation and government work in the Delhi High Court. As Standing Counsel for the Government of India she has appeared in matters across criminal, civil and administrative law. Beyond the courtroom she is a frequent commentator on Indian legal-policy questions and on Hindu civilisational and women's issues. Frequently asked questions Who is Monika Arora? Monika Arora is an Indian advocate practising in the Supreme Court of India and the Delhi High Court, Standing Counsel for the Government of India, and a co-author of Delhi Riots 2020: The Untold Story published by Garuda Prakashan. What is Delhi Riots 2020: The Untold Story about? It is a citizen-led investigation into the February 2020 communal violence in north-east Delhi, co-authored with Sonali Chitalkar and Prerna Malhotra. After the original publisher withdrew the title, Garuda Prakashan published it in 2020 and it became one of the year's most widely-read non-fiction books in India. What is the Group of Intellectuals and Academicians (GIA)? GIA is a public-interest forum co-founded by Monika Arora that produces fact-finding reports and policy commentary on questions of Indian public life. Its citizen fact-finding report on the Delhi riots fed directly into Delhi Riots 2020: The Untold Story . Where can I buy Monika Arora's book? Delhi Riots 2020: The Untold Story is published by Garuda Prakashan and available on this page with free shipping in India.

View Author Profile
Shruti Mishra

Dr. Shruti Ranjana Mishra teaches in the Department of Hindi in PGDAV college (evening). She has authored three books on Hindi Sahitya and regularly publishes research papers in UGC listed journals.

View Author Profile
Sonali Chitalkar photo
Sonali Chitalkar

S onali Chitalkar is Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Miranda House University of Delhi. Her area of specialization is International Relations with a focus on Conflict Resolution. She has been working on the state of Jammu and Kashmir in the last few years as a part of Peace facilitation and conflict resolution committee. She has also worked on inter-regional aspirations in Jammu and Kashmir, spent time studying on ground the evolution of politics in the former State. Her doctoral thesis is on Education Policy in Jammu and Kashmir. She is currently working on the framework of an Indic Theory of Gender as part of her interest in Decolonisation of the Indian mind and Indigenous Political Theory.

View Author Profile
WA